It seems that you are unregistered. Please register with us by clicking here.
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
![]() | Register | Arcade | Members List | Calendar | Mark Forums Read | ![]() |
| | | | |||||||
| The Cleveland Browns Place for all discussion about our beloved Browns. |
![]() |
| | LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
| ||||
| Quote:
Should be good.
__________________ |
| ||||
|
How did I know I would come here and find an Alex Smith related post today ha ha ha. The guy who completed all of 3 passes to his WR's in a championship game.. Game manager is right.. He does make those 1 or 2 good throws a game for big plays.. I will give him that.. He is a good game manager and is capable of making plays.. However, he is not the guy who will LEAD the team with his arm.. Flacco is much of the same.. I agree. I think Flacco has more upside though. It's going to be a good superbowl. The Giants are just stacked at WR.. If Nicks is healthy.. Nicks, Manningham and Cruz are an amazing 3 to have out in patterns.
__________________ *************************** Individuals win trophies. TEAMS win Championships! |
| ||||
| Quote:
Somehow some of you guys seem to think our common sense doesn't tell us we need to upgrade many positions. What I fail to understand is how your common sense doesn't tell you that getting a shot at one of the 2 best QBs in the draft, a guy who has it all ...the arm, the brains, the character, the wheels, the intangibles ...doesn't come along very often. If all you McCoy apologists think this team will improve to even 6 wins next season with Colt under center, then you are also gambling a huge amount on making Colt your franchise QB. 6 wins will not get one of the top 2 QBs in the draft. If Colt fails like he more than likely will ...you're talking about drafting the 3rd or 4th or worse QBs in the draft trying to hit on your franchise guy. Logic tells you that lowers your chances of getting that stud. We are taking a bigger risk by leaving Colt McCoy under center and betting on him, then in drafting an elite prospect @ QB while we can, especially now that you don't have to ruin your cap to do so. Take THE guy while you can. And what's great about this free agency crop is you can REALLY upgrade your WR crop, as well as your defense if you go out and get the right guys. If we do this right, we'll have a QBOTF with an unlimited ceiling, either a young #1 speed demon of a WR, or a pass rushing DE or LB, and a stud RT ...starting for us next year, all with your 1st 3 picks, not even looking at the rest of the draft & FA! IMO it'll be RG3 or a trade down. Too many other options @ WR to waste that pick there. (unless we pull off grabbing Luck)
__________________ |
| ||||||
| Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
What exactly did you like about our offensive firepower that Colt had to work with this year? Was it the awesome play of Lauvoa, RT and Pinky? How about the nice turnstile at RB? Then we always have Greg Little as the number one, an idiot in Momass masquerading as a pro trying to run a simple route and hybrid TE's who always have concussions. You got to be kidding me right? Then again Shurms was reminding everybody of Mike Martz with his playcalling. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I would be all for a trade down if Blackmon is gone, but I am not sure passing on kalil is a good idea either. I need to find out more about him to see if he is truly dominant and can convert to RT successfully. A trade down unfortunately is going to throw the fanbase and media like the Grosster into a negative tailspin, but if it is the right thing to do, then do it. Say no to Richardson at four, but given the way these guys treated Hillis, I doubt they would ever take an RB that high---nor should they.
__________________ |
| ||||
|
Wow, you misrepresent "all those" who want to draft a QB as believing he alone will take us to the "promised land" and I respond to it and that makes me touchy? I haven't seen a single person state we are a QB away from winning a Superbowl. Not a single one. Please correct me if I am wrong. Absolutes? Um, didn't utter one single absolute. Ever heard of a prospect? That's what I called RG3 ...how is that an absolute? Again, logic not to mention common sense suggests if you can draft the cream of the crop at the top of the draft, irregardless of the position, you are more likely to hit there than later on. All the useless lists in the world do not prove your point. For every top 5 QB who has failed in this league you guys list, we can list 100s who have failed everywhere else in the draft ...so? Those lists illustrate nothing other than every once in a long while you can find a needle in a haystack and land a good starting NFL QB later in the draft. Um, OK ...I guess we and all other teams should just pass on all QBs until at best round 2 from here on out. Weird logic. And who here called Colt garbage? He'll be a really solid backup after Wallace is gone ...maybe even win us some games if he ever has to step in for the starter. Let me ask you this, if we tried to trade Colt McCoy right now, what could we get for him? Maybe a 4th rounder? Whether he has the weapons or not, you can analyze the QB ...he's had enough time to show me he's certainly not elite at anything, can't really think of anything he is above average at, can peg a few things he's been very average at, and a handful of things he's been sub-par at. Unless we're scoring him on locker room speeches about putting hay in the barn ...that's the stuff of legends. Hey, I thought the kid might have what it took in the NCO ...although towards the end of year one I was beginning to have doubts. Then, I bought into the ridiculous notion that he was born to be a WCO QB (why I don't know) and he failed miserably there in many areas ...weapons or not. You saw what an above average (maybe some would say elite) QB can still manage to do in the face of relentless pressure in Eli Manning this past game ...guess what, he still made his reads, went through his progressions, and delivered the ball in stride to his receivers even with guys harassing him all night. McCoy doesn't even do those things with adequate protection. I really wanted to believe in 3rd round miracles too, I wanted the next Drew Brees ...I was right there with you guys, but now we have a shot at a legitimate franchise QB and the last one we rolled the dice on I thought was pretty darned good. I'd love to see what Couch could do with this team in his prime. *I should add to this ...defense & special teams, a thousand times yes. It's downright unacceptable for how far our special teams has fallen in one single year. What's the excuse there ...different system? Pathetic.
__________________ |
| ||||||
| Quote:
Uh, calling guys apologists would be considered an absolute and in some cases from a cocky perspective a slam at some otherwise really knowledgeable football fans intelligence. Yeah, and duh also can mean blowing a top pick......duh! There is no "weird logic", it is called being patient with a young QB and giving him a chance with some actual talent and a year to implement an offense. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Some of us predicted that fans would blame this season on Colt when it was obvious what a disaster it was and sure as shit, here we are. The funny thing is, I am open to RGIII if he shows his wares and some other options, but I don't like the fact people have basically scapegoated Colt and made assumptions about him given what he showed under Mangie and what he had to work with this year. He outplayed Bradford this year folks.
__________________ |
| |||||||
|
Riff, let me first say ...great to have you getting into some discussions again, you have been missed. I would also like to point out, you skipped past many of my central points ...but fair enough. Let me address a few of your rebuttals. Quote:
![]() Quote:
Quote:
So true! And we'll be taking that risk no matter what position we go after @ 4. Quote:
He has way to many other concerns to argue non concerns like that, although height & arm are nice ...they aren't the end all be all, at least not for me.I agree ...and I'm sorry, as tough as I have been on Shurmur, Colt shoulders part of this. Colt has not made the players around him better. Colt has not demanded excellence. Colt has not taken his team by the scruff of the neck and let them have it for lazy or inadequate practice & play. For all of Colts bluster during the preseason about how he had the playbook down, I sure didn't see that during the regular season. If he truly did have the playbook nailed as he claimed ...man he should have done better. I'm sorry, but I think if Colt wants a chance to be a starter in this league, he needs someone who is going to push him to the limits and squeeze every last ounce of talent out of him ...that's not going to happen with this coaching staff. We need a QB who can transcend this soft group of football coaches and FO types by using his raw God given talent to make them look better than they are. That's really my only hope for these guys right now. Quote:
Let's face it, Colt looked promising in his rookie year in last years system ...with what he has claimed was ZERO preparation via playing with the ones and/or having the playbook or whatever it was he claimed in his book. Colt was up at the line last season, barking out audibles and looking much more like a legit NFL prospect than he ever even sniffed this season in this system and under this coaching. That's after a full season of learning the system, and having the playbook, and working with the ones. Like it or not, we are running what we are, and we have the type of coaches we have. If Colt ever had a chance at success in this elite league, it was extinguished when Holmgren took this team in the direction he did. Perhaps Colt will resurrect his career if he ever finds that again, be he still imo does not possess the talent nor the ceiling that RG3 has. Quote:
Quote:
(was never a fan of Bradford btw, but there were a lot of excuses over there for his play as well)
__________________ |
| ||||
|
It's getting tough to read in here again, certain posters are starting to drop into camp qb, and the rest of us are getting labeled "Colt guys." It's starting to sound a whole lot like "Quinn fags" to me. I'm sure almost everyone here would be thrilled with Luck, hell, I would. Problem is, with all the holes we have, many of us see it a waste of a pick tossing yet another project into the fire with no protection on the right and no weapons. It's been pointed out time and time again in thread after thread, how most successful teams build a team with a journeyman qb while building a cockpit and defense. No successful team started with the qb, and no successful qb was successful without weapons and protection.
__________________ Myself: "If you find no one listens when you talk to them, just start talking to yourself instead, then, everyone listens." Scott Glenn: "If you don't stand for something, you'll fall for anything." |
| ||||
|
Don't think we're starting with the QB. We're a few pieces away from a talented offense ...that's it. Kind of crazy people can't have an opinion about drafting a QB here without people getting up in arms. Relax and enjoy the off season. I'll continue to debate on upgrading our talent across the board, QB included especially when we have a shot at a special one ..."project" is your opinion which you are entitled to. You won't find me starting 1000 threads about it though, I promise.
__________________ |
| ||||
|
Anyone but D.A. That guy sucked, balls.
__________________ Follow me on twitter @BigHoagowski and @WeWalkTheLines Walk the Line - Cleveland Sports News, Analysis, Rumors and Musings |
| ||||
| Quote:
Did John Elway make anyone on Denver better in his first 2-3 years? Thank you for being honest you would have found great reason to cut him too. Did Drew Brees make anyone before Antonio Gates and Keenan McCardell better in his first 3 years? I'm glad you're honest when you could have accurately predicted there would have never been a Superbowl Championship or an MVP season in his future because he made NOBODY better in his first 3 years of starting. Did Troy Aikman make anyone in Dallas better in his first 2 years of starting? When they went 1-15 they could have drafted a QB and many of their fans just like you wanted that QB up if they weren't already thinking Steve Walsh was the answer. It seems like there's alot of fans today that pay no attention to the history of this game and what a young QB going to a bad franchise goes through. Those QBs I exemplified above are either in the Hall of Fame or will be very soon for their levels of excellence. ALL won Superbowls and frequented Pro Bowls. Early on, they had people like you Gabe saying their franchise just needed to draft another QB because they weren't performing miracles in the first 32 starts. Do you remember how pissed you were at Stuckey the day he fumbled away the OT game to the NY Jets at their 30 yard line? I saw enough promise in McCoy in 2010 to excuse throwing into a crowded phone booth in 2011. Right now, we don't know if RGIII is the next Akili Smith or the next Michael Vick. I do know RGIII had to medical red shirt for an ACL blowout and left a 2011 game early for a concussion; and the backup put up great stats when he got to play. I also know how often Michael Vick can't answer the bell on game day. I just see a collision course with James Harrison if we draft the QB draw. If the NFL was ANYTHING like the Big 12 - don't you think we'd have 1 example of excellence at QB to talk about by now? Clearly we don't so you want to throw out this Big 12 QB and draft the next one? What's gonna be different this time? I WANT Andrew Luck but that doesn't mean I gotta pretend the second highest rated QB has to be in his class. You gotta be careful. I was once the BIGGEST Vince Young fan; because I read he was the #1 rated PASSER (not a misprint) in Division IA after his final season as a junior. In the pros, he was successful all the way up until a hammy/groin sentenced him to being a pocket passer. As you saw Roethlisberger confined to a pogostick - what happens when an improvise king gets handcuffed to the pocket and play wired into the huddle? He's a fraction of what he was. Long story short, the Big 12 ALWAYS has a cluster of guys with the highest passer ratings. Unfortunately, what happens when they all get to the NFL? Defense, closing speeds and contested routes = culture shock and overhelm. YES, we currently have a Big 12 QB at the affordable rate of round 3 exchange value. I don't feel comfortable throwing him out of the batter's box at strike 2 for the reasons I specified above ONLY to look right back at the Big 12. AGAIN, I'm a huge Andrew Luck fan looking at the supply of Andrew Lucks for a team slated to draft #4.
__________________ Last edited by Flugel; 01-24-2012 at 07:16 AM. |
![]() |
| Tags |
| 2011, 2012, awesome, board, bradford, brady quinn, browns, cleveland, coaching, college, colt mccoy, combine, contest, controls, cribbs, defense, draft, dropped passes, football, free agency, funny, god, greg little, health, hillis, holmgren, hybrid, injury, james harrison, jets, love, mccoy, media, nba, ncaa, nfl, nfl draft, offense, passer rating, passing, playoffs, position, prospects, record, season, shurmur, special teams, speed, stats, superbowl, tebow, trade, troy smith, wallace, ward, wco |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |