Final draft grades

[YtownBacker]

Originally Posted by Riffer X

Walter is my least favorite, hands down.

This was a solid draft, he's basing most of it off of taking McCoy over Clausen and reaching for Ward, which is his opinion.

Did someone run this guys dick through a meat grinder or what? He gives Hardesty a grade of a "D" because he felt we should have taken a QB. WTF, the guy is a potential premier running back.

The only pick you can have a question with is Ward and obviously Heckert and Mangini wanted to get rid of the "soft" label for their defense. Ward is one hell of a ballplayer. Health is the only reason I wouldn't give that pick a "B".

As I stated Steuber gave us a solid "B" for the draft.

[kydawgfan]

Draft grading means nothing it takes a couple years to truly grade a draft other than that walter gave one of the worst pitches for his browns draft grade that i have ever seen...what a retard..

[hiwaygal]

I think we need to post how all the draft guru's graded us. It would be really funny to see how disconnected and unrealistic THEIR prognostication was.

These draft gurus may know the skills and qualities of the college players, but they DONT' know when or who will draft them. Just becuase they had Clausen going before Tebow meant that they KNEW it would happen. I find it hysterical that they're getting all bent out of shape, mad, and even angry that teams didn't follow their order of approval. Bunch of dumb-asses.

I give us an A...and after all, my opinion is the only one that really matters.

[Riffer X]

Originally Posted by YtownBacker

Did someone run this guys dick through a meat grinder or what? He gives Hardesty a grade of a "D" because he felt we should have taken a QB. WTF, the guy is a potential premier running back.

The only pick you can have a question with is Ward and obviously Heckert and Mangini wanted to get rid of the "soft" label for their defense. Ward is one hell of a ballplayer. Health is the only reason I wouldn't give that pick a "B".

As I stated Steuber gave us a solid "B" for the draft.

LOL. As I stated earlier, look at it like this: We got our stud corner, stud safety and stud back all before we got our future franchise QB.

Look at it like that, and that's before getting into a potential Colston type at WR in round freaking six.

[Vegasdogg]

Originally Posted by Jax Dawg

As I said in the other thread he just makes himself look like an idiot for busting on us for not taking the QB in the top of the 2nd where everybody thought we would take him, busts on us again for not reaching again for QB in the late 2nd and then tops it all off by busting on us for being patient enough to get the QB everybody thought we were taking in the 2nd in the latter part of the 3rd!

Originally Posted by golfer

"85. Colt McCoy, QB, Texas
I don't like Colt McCoy as a prospect. I could be wrong, but I think he's a mini-Kyle Orton. Having said that, he's a great value toward the bottom of Round 3. He's a natural fit for Cleveland's West Coast offense, but why then did the Browns pass on him twice on Day 2? That's the huge question. (Pick Grade: A)"

I love this one...."I really question whether or not this kid just sucks eggs and is terrible. But why didn't the Browns draft him higher?????" is essentially what he said.

So we should reach for a guy he doesn't like higher in the draft based on need?

I am reading this guy and I could not believe his explanations. So we should have taken Colt earlier essentially because you don't like him but he should have been taken higher? Dude had to be stoned when he wrote that, but then again when you rush out your opinions on 32 teams, you are bound to say stupid shit. And his entire response to our draft was about need, need, need. Hey Walter drafting for need is pretty much how we got this bad in the first place.