Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 24 of 53

Thread: Dolphins position match up.

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    6,003
    Thanks
    114
    Thanked 382 Times in 220 Posts

    Default Dolphins position match up.

    Ryan Tannefail vs Brandon Weeden.

    This match up is going to be the most interesting and likely will define which team wins. Regardless of who we think is better or worse the fact is these guys are both first round picks who put up almost identical numbers last season. They both had very encouraging preseasons, and both have new tools at their disposal be it coaching or players.

    I cannot pick one or the other because I think their supporting cast could very well be the difference. We aren't sure if Brandon is going to have reliable targets, but we aren't sure if Ryan's line can keep him on his feet long enough to impact the game. How those around either signal caller play is going to determine who puts their stamp on the game.

    Trent Richardson vs Lamar Miller.


    I honestly don't feel I need to say too much. Trent is coming off a strong rookie year despite all his injuries while Lamar Miller was hardly able to hold off Daniel Thomas for the starting job. Trent is going to turn heads this year. He's not only a fantastic rusher but his blocking and catching is just as good. Mr. Richardson wins this one comfortably, and I think the Browns first team run stopping has looked better than expected so far.

    Browns o-line vs Miami front 7.

    Without Cam Wake this would not even be close. Cam is one of the best pass rushers in the NFL and if Mitch Schwartz can handle him or not is a big question (Though going against Kruger all off season is a big help). Dion Jordan likely won't be healthy, and that's probably best for the Dolphins because Joe Thomas is the best in the business. Oliver Vernon will be left with Joe. Meanwhile, Starks and Soliai will be left split between Mack, Greco and Gilkey. Greco is above solid, and Alex Mack is a pro-bowler. Gilkey is the question, but I've like what I've seen so far - and his best game as a Brown has come against the firing 4-3 of the Lions.

    As for Misi, Wheeler and Ellerbe I wouldn't be shocked to see them not blitzing as much, opting to make it difficult for Brandon in a more coverage based role. Phillip Wheeler made a strong impression in coverage last year (6 passes defended) but was part of the awful Raiders team. Their run stopping should be strong but I don't think they will put on a dominant pass rush.

    Miami o-line vs Browns front 7.

    Browns win. Miami's o-line is awful at best while between Kruger, Sheard, Jackson, Robertson, Taylor, Bryant and Rubin the Browns boast a combined 27.5 sacks from the 2012 season (That's 7.5 more than the Jags total team). If I heard correctly, Miami's current LT gave up more sacks and hurries than any other lineman in 2012 while playing at RT, and according to multiple Miami writers their o-line was laughable during training camp.

    Browns receivers vs Miami secondary.


    I was going to give this to Miami convincingly until I saw they've listed Dimitri Patterson as their #2 corner. This guy was so bad he couldn't earn time over Buster Skrine. The Browns won't be afraid to mix Greg Little, Davone Bess and Travis Benjamin to try and exploit him. I thought for sure Will Davis would get the nod over him. At safety, the Dolphins have Reshad Jones and Chris Clemons. Both are veteran 5th round picks still trying to find their feet entering their 4th and 5th seasons respectively. Jones had somewhat of a break out season last year so Brandon will have to be careful there. Meanwhile, Brent Grimes has impressed. I'll still give this to the Dolphins, simply because we don't know what we're going to get out of our guys, but they certainly don't come without their holes. If Jordan Cameron can repeat his antics from the Lions game, the Browns will be looking good.

    Miami receivers vs Browns secondary.

    It all comes down to Buster Skrine and Tashaun Gipson. The Dolphins aren't as great at receiver as their fan base seems to think. First, we should note Joe Haden has handled Mike Wallace at his best in Shitsburgh, and he's struggled to find his feet in Miami. Brian Hartline is coming off a 1,000 yard season but he only managed to turn that in to 1 touchdown. He was also inconsistent. 4 games of 8+ receptions but also had 6 games with 3 receptions or less. Shockingly, that game span he had only 11 receptions but 36 targets. When he's cold, he is awful. The Dolphins also look to be starting Charles Clay at TE who is a developing 6th round pick they've tried hard to hide away on the depth chart. The Dolphins have also signed Brandon Gibson from the Rams to be their new Davone Bess, but how much chemistry he has with Ryan in his new system is yet to be seen.

    Overall, I don't see how it's so easy for people to write off the Browns secondary. Sure, we've got two guys with questions, but they aren't facing 7 clones of Megatron. I'll give the slight edge to Miami, but it's only slight because of the two aforementioned guys that are still developing.

    Overall.

    This is a game I think the Browns should win. I get it people think it will be close but truth be told I will be pissed if the Browns don't smack them one. In the first two preseason games the Browns lifted and showed they are tired of being pushed around. The same needs to be shown against the Dolphins who aren't world beaters by any stretch. If the Browns don't win by a touchdown or two, and convincingly control the game, I'll be disappointed. It's early and it's going to take time for our young team to really gel, but I think they ultimately want the same thing I do. Bring it on, and go Browns.

    (Used Miami's current depth chart on their official website, so not sure how accurate.)

    Thoughts? (TL-DR is not a thought! )

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    10,235
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 111 Times in 96 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by brownsdownunder View Post
    Ryan Tannefail vs Brandon Weeden.

    This match up is going to be the most interesting and likely will define which team wins. Regardless of who we think is better or worse the fact is these guys are both first round picks who put up almost identical numbers last season. They both had very encouraging preseasons, and both have new tools at their disposal be it coaching or players.

    I cannot pick one or the other because I think their supporting cast could very well be the difference. We aren't sure if Brandon is going to have reliable targets, but we aren't sure if Ryan's line can keep him on his feet long enough to impact the game. How those around either signal caller play is going to determine who puts their stamp on the game.

    Trent Richardson vs Lamar Miller.

    I honestly don't feel I need to say too much. Trent is coming off a strong rookie year despite all his injuries while Lamar Miller was hardly able to hold off Daniel Thomas for the starting job. Trent is going to turn heads this year. He's not only a fantastic rusher but his blocking and catching is just as good. Mr. Richardson wins this one comfortably, and I think the Browns first team run stopping has looked better than expected so far.

    Browns o-line vs Miami front 7.

    Without Cam Wake this would not even be close. Cam is one of the best pass rushers in the NFL and if Mitch Schwartz can handle him or not is a big question (Though going against Kruger all off season is a big help). Dion Jordan likely won't be healthy, and that's probably best for the Dolphins because Joe Thomas is the best in the business. Oliver Vernon will be left with Joe. Meanwhile, Starks and Soliai will be left split between Mack, Greco and Gilkey. Greco is above solid, and Alex Mack is a pro-bowler. Gilkey is the question, but I've like what I've seen so far - and his best game as a Brown has come against the firing 4-3 of the Lions.

    As for Misi, Wheeler and Ellerbe I wouldn't be shocked to see them not blitzing as much, opting to make it difficult for Brandon in a more coverage based role. Phillip Wheeler made a strong impression in coverage last year (6 passes defended) but was part of the awful Raiders team. Their run stopping should be strong but I don't think they will put on a dominant pass rush.

    Miami o-line vs Browns front 7.

    Browns win. Miami's o-line is awful at best while between Kruger, Sheard, Jackson, Robertson, Taylor, Bryant and Rubin the Browns boast a combined 27.5 sacks from the 2012 season (That's 7.5 more than the Jags total team). If I heard correctly, Miami's current LT gave up more sacks and hurries than any other lineman in 2012 while playing at RT, and according to multiple Miami writers their o-line was laughable during training camp.

    Browns receivers vs Miami secondary.

    I was going to give this to Miami convincingly until I saw they've listed Dimitri Patterson as their #2 corner. This guy was so bad he couldn't earn time over Buster Skrine. The Browns won't be afraid to mix Greg Little, Davone Bess and Travis Benjamin to try and exploit him. I thought for sure Will Davis would get the nod over him. At safety, the Dolphins have Reshad Jones and Chris Clemons. Both are veteran 5th round picks still trying to find their feet entering their 4th and 5th seasons respectively. Jones had somewhat of a break out season last year so Brandon will have to be careful there. Meanwhile, Brent Grimes has impressed. I'll still give this to the Dolphins, simply because we don't know what we're going to get out of our guys, but they certainly don't come without their holes. If Jordan Cameron can repeat his antics from the Lions game, the Browns will be looking good.

    Miami receivers vs Browns secondary.

    It all comes down to Buster Skrine and Tashaun Gipson. The Dolphins aren't as great at receiver as their fan base seems to think. First, we should note Joe Haden has handled Mike Wallace at his best in Shitsburgh, and he's struggled to find his feet in Miami. Brian Hartline is coming off a 1,000 yard season but he only managed to turn that in to 1 touchdown. He was also inconsistent. 4 games of 8+ receptions but also had 6 games with 3 receptions or less. Shockingly, that game span he had only 11 receptions but 36 targets. When he's cold, he is awful. The Dolphins also look to be starting Charles Clay at TE who is a developing 6th round pick they've tried hard to hide away on the depth chart. The Dolphins have also signed Brandon Gibson from the Rams to be their new Davone Bess, but how much chemistry he has with Ryan in his new system is yet to be seen.

    Overall, I don't see how it's so easy for people to write off the Browns secondary. Sure, we've got two guys with questions, but they aren't facing 7 clones of Megatron. I'll give the slight edge to Miami, but it's only slight because of the two aforementioned guys that are still developing.

    Overall.

    This is a game I think the Browns should win. I get it people think it will be close but truth be told I will be pissed if the Browns don't smack them one. In the first two preseason games the Browns lifted and showed they are tired of being pushed around. The same needs to be shown against the Dolphins who aren't world beaters by any stretch. If the Browns don't win by a touchdown or two, and convincingly control the game, I'll be disappointed. It's early and it's going to take time for our young team to really gel, but I think they ultimately want the same thing I do. Bring it on, and go Browns.

    (Used Miami's current depth chart on their official website, so not sure how accurate.)

    Thoughts? (TL-DR is not a thought! )
    Tannenhill could be a little more effective than Weeden in this game and he has some mobility which Weeden lacks. However, Tannenhill and the Miami offense have not looked all that sharp this pre-season, and this Miami offense is not Andew Luck and Colts. If Tannenhill gets more time than expected to throw, the Browns are in big trouble. Key is to get a lot of constant pressure on Tannehill who may make a couple of mistakes.

    TRich better than Miller but Dolphins have a backup RB who is far superior to what the Browns have.

    The defensive line as a whole is one of the key strengths of the whole Miami team, so I think your assessment is incorrect. They have guys who can rush besides Wake, who is a load. I expect the Dolphins D-line will be troublesome for Weeden.

    The Miami O-line has a couple of capable players but you are correct, this has been a big problem this summer and Browns should get plenty of pressure. How well the Browns do in this area will determine the outcome of the game. This is the Dolphins primary weakness.

    Re the secondary, I thought Patterson was terrible last year but he has been very adequate in game action I have seen in the past month. Hall of Famer Bob Griese, who is the color analyst for the Dolphins, said: "I'm very comfortable with the Dolphins secondary and Dimitri Patterson is a terrific addition." Overall, Dolphins have a decent secondary and will give the Browns a few problems, although not insurmountable.

    You may be underestimating the Dolphins receiving corps and, in my judgment, Brandon Gibson, who replaced Bess, has been excellent in pre-season. I'll predict right now Gibson will hurt the Browns some. Dolphins took a heavy blow when TE Keller went down and that hurts them big-time. I honestly have no idea how well the Browns secondary will perform so I'm not sure how this part of the battle is going to turn out.

    Overall: This will be a close game that either team can win. This is a key game for Cleveland because this is a team they can beat. There will not be many winnable games on the Browns schedule this year.
    Last edited by AttackOffense; 09-02-2013 at 10:37 AM.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Winnipeg
    Posts
    9,852
    Thanks
    402
    Thanked 173 Times in 142 Posts
    Blog Entries
    29

    Default

    Great write-up BDU, I'm going to add my thoughts as well:

    QUARTERBACKS: I give the advantage to Tannehill simply because I think without Josh Gordon in the lineup, and counting all the injuries that the team has inferior offensive talent right now. Weeden will not have as bad a game as he had week one of last year but I'm not sure if he will be able to get comfortable and into a rhythm and the same goes to Tannehill because I think both teams have good pass-rush which will make headaches for the QB's all game long...

    Advantage: Miami (BARELY...)

    RUNNING BACK: The Dolphins have been trying to make something happen at running back since Daniel Thomas decided not to work out for them (but boy did he look great against us in that game last season) I give T-Rich the edge here simply because he's a more physically talented running back. IF he can keep himself from stutter stepping all game long I think he will have the stronger game and the stronger season overall. That being said, I wouldn't be surprised if Miami's running backs looked better against us than they should, again.

    Advantage: Cleveland

    OFFENSIVE LINE: Miami got RID of one of the best LT in football because he might be developing injury prone-ness. We've got JT. Both teams are dealing with a bit of a bandaid job right now ours is more due to injuries than Miami's spending a ton of money. I think even with the injuries to our offensive line we stand comparably to Miami, if we were healthy I would give us the edge.

    Advantage: Even.

    DEFENSIVE FRONT SEVEN: I agree with BDU that if the Dolphins do not have Cam Wake (a former CFL'er btw ) or Dion Jordan then the Browns have the advantage here (as we're only likely to miss Sheard, maybe?) and should pose the greater threat. I wouldn't doubt Miami's ability to get at the QB in spite of our O-Line health but overall I expect our defense to generate a more consistent pass rush than Miami. I think Miami has a pretty good D though and even if they're missing Cameron Wake we will not have it very easy.

    Advantage: Cleveland

    DEFENSIVE SECONDARY: Dimitri Patterson is listed as their #2 CB over Grimes? Colour me confused... I think depth wise, Miami has more even out talent in their secondary where we are fielding more un-proven talent. I think Haden is a better corner than Smith and we've got better CB's than Dimitri Patterson... Safety... I call it even as well.

    Advantage: Even.

    Overall: Agreed with BDU, this is a game the Browns should win. I want to see that the team is ready to set the tone early and keep it for the whole game, that is a sign to me the team came to play prepared. The play of our o-line and the play of our secondary will IMO, dictate victory. I have no doubts our pass rush will generate problems for Miami and I don't doubt that T-Rich will come to play. How well will the wide out's play? I've seen enough mental gaffes in the pre-season to think that our pass attack will have it's ups and downs as everyone works to get on the same page with the new offense. I predicted the Browns will lose a frustrating game and I still stand by that prediction. I think on paper we have the advantage but we will find a way to lose this one. Maybe that's my cynicism creeping back early.
    BROWNS 2015: WORLD'S BESTEST OFFENSIVE LINE.
    "I just do not get worked up over games anymore. I realized some time ago there is no point in getting worked up over them.
    I have no control over the outcome, it has no impact on me personally, and I have little to no actual facts to work from on properly analyzing the results." - Masters

    "It's pertinent that the Browns address the quarterback situation. I don't care if it's a trade or someone in the draft but going into the season with all bets placed on Johnny is a terrible idea. Maybe he does wreck this league, but adding another quarterback is like carrying around a condom - I'd rather have one and not need it, than need it and not have one." - brownsdownunder

    WOOF WOOF WOOF!


  4. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    6,003
    Thanks
    114
    Thanked 382 Times in 220 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by AttackOffense View Post
    Tannenhill could be a little more effective than Weeden in this game and he has some mobility which Weeden lacks. However, Tannenhill and the Miami offense have not looked all that sharp this pre-season, and this Miami offense is not Andew Luck and Colts. If Tannenhill gets more time than expected to throw, the Browns are in big trouble. Key is to get a lot of constant pressure on Tannehill who may make a couple of mistakes.

    TRich better than Miller but Dolphins have a backup RB who is far superior to what the Browns have.

    The defensive line as a whole is one of the key strengths of the whole Miami team, so I think your assessment is incorrect. They have guys who can rush besides Wake, who is a load. I expect the Dolphins D-line will be troublesome for Weeden.

    The Miami O-line has a couple of capable players but you are correct, this has been a big problem this summer and Browns should get plenty of pressure. How well the Browns do in this area will determine the outcome of the game. This is the Dolphins primary weakness.

    Re the secondary, I thought Patterson was terrible last year but he has been very adequate in game action I have seen in the past month. Hall of Famer Bob Griese, who is the color analyst for the Dolphins, said: "I'm very comfortable with the Dolphins secondary and Dimitri Patterson is a terrific addition." Overall, Dolphins have a decent secondary and will give the Browns a few problems, although not insurmountable.

    You may be underestimating the Dolphins receiving corps and, in my judgment, Brandon Gibson, who replaced Bess, has been excellent in pre-season. I'll predict right now Gibson will hurt the Browns some. Dolphins took a heavy blow when TE Keller went down and that hurts them big-time. I honestly have no idea how well the Browns secondary will perform so I'm not sure how this part of the battle is going to turn out.

    Overall: This will be a close game that either team can win. This is a key game for Cleveland because this is a team they can beat. There will not be many winnable games on the Browns schedule this year.
    Who are the guys who rush besides Wake? Soliai is coming in to his 8th year and has only 3.5 sacks to his name. Randy Starks is coming in to his 10th year and has a much more impressive 32.5 sacks but is on the downhill. He's not been the same monster for a while. He's also questionable for the opener with a knee injury, so even if he does play, he's probably not 100%. There is Oliver Vernon on the other side but he's far from a proven pass rusher, as evidenced by the Dolphins replacing him with Jordan. I just don't see any other monsters on their line apart from Cam Wake. I've certainly not seen any dominance from them in recent years. It's a team strength, but how strong is a whole new question.

    I don't think I've underestimated their receivers, either. If Brandon Gibson is the best they have then it speaks volumes. He's had one good year, two very average years and one solid year. The Rams moved on from him because they felt he wasn't an answer for Sam Bradford. In the 2012 season he was very bland. Two good games but the rest a lot of 2/3 catches for 30/40 yards type deal. It's consistent but it falls well short of a guy being a game changer. He did score 5 touchdowns but 2 of them came from the Jets awful goal line. He only had 4 touchdowns in the previous 3 seasons (Admittedly, he missed time with injury in all those seasons) so it's hard to see him, like Hartline, as a points monster.

    I just don't see either of those grouping being so great.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    10,235
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 111 Times in 96 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by brownsdownunder View Post
    Who are the guys who rush besides Wake? Soliai is coming in to his 8th year and has only 3.5 sacks to his name. Randy Starks is coming in to his 10th year and has a much more impressive 32.5 sacks but is on the downhill. He's not been the same monster for a while. He's also questionable for the opener with a knee injury, so even if he does play, he's probably not 100%. There is Oliver Vernon on the other side but he's far from a proven pass rusher, as evidenced by the Dolphins replacing him with Jordan. I just don't see any other monsters on their line apart from Cam Wake. I've certainly not seen any dominance from them in recent years. It's a team strength, but how strong is a whole new question.

    I don't think I've underestimated their receivers, either. If Brandon Gibson is the best they have then it speaks volumes. He's had one good year, two very average years and one solid year. The Rams moved on from him because they felt he wasn't an answer for Sam Bradford. In the 2012 season he was very bland. Two good games but the rest a lot of 2/3 catches for 30/40 yards type deal. It's consistent but it falls well short of a guy being a game changer. He did score 5 touchdowns but 2 of them came from the Jets awful goal line. He only had 4 touchdowns in the previous 3 seasons (Admittedly, he missed time with injury in all those seasons) so it's hard to see him, like Hartline, as a points monster.

    I just don't see either of those grouping being so great.
    I have the advantage of seeing these guys play more than you do. Of course, that doesn't mean I'm right and you are wrong.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    6,003
    Thanks
    114
    Thanked 382 Times in 220 Posts

    Default

    Smith ain't with the Fish no more, EE. Grimes is their #1 and Patterson is their #2.

    Also, have a read up on their line, it's gone to hell in a hand basket. It really isn't even close to even mate. I'll link you up some stories while you get the chap stick because you're going to be licking your lips like crazy.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    10,235
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 111 Times in 96 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by brownsdownunder View Post
    Smith ain't with the Fish no more, EE. Grimes is their #1 and Patterson is their #2.

    Also, have a read up on their line, it's gone to hell in a hand basket. It really isn't even close to even mate. I'll link you up some stories while you get the chap stick because you're going to be licking your lips like crazy.
    Sean Smith is a big CB that I wanted the Browns to pursue. Where is he -- KC?

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    6,003
    Thanks
    114
    Thanked 382 Times in 220 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by AttackOffense View Post
    I have the advantage of seeing these guys play more than you do. Of course, that doesn't mean I'm right and you are wrong.
    I have game pass every year and watch most games unless they're so boring I couldn't sit through it or I'm busy. I've got every game on demand from the past few years if there is anything you think I might have missed or might help that I can go watch right now?

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Tucson, AZ
    Posts
    6,888
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 27 Times in 23 Posts

    Default

    Nice writeup for the mostpart BDU. The Battle between Lamar Miller and Daniel Thomas..was a lot like our QB battle.. It never really existed except in the media.. Lamar Miller was never in doubt for the lead back role.

    The big balance of power in this game falls in favor of our D. I expect our D to win this game. Miami's OL is not very good and that advantage should be easy enough to exploit to where it throws the win over to our side.
    ***************************
    I love fishing. You put that line in the water and you don't know what's on the other end. Your imagination is under there. ~Robert Altman

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    10,235
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 111 Times in 96 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by brownsdownunder View Post
    I have game pass every year and watch most games unless they're so boring I couldn't sit through it or I'm busy. I've got every game on demand from the past few years if there is anything you think I might have missed or might help that I can go watch right now?

    Good post!

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by brownsdownunder View Post
    Who are the guys who rush besides Wake? Soliai is coming in to his 8th year and has only 3.5 sacks to his name. Randy Starks is coming in to his 10th year and has a much more impressive 32.5 sacks but is on the downhill. He's not been the same monster for a while. He's also questionable for the opener with a knee injury, so even if he does play, he's probably not 100%. There is Oliver Vernon on the other side but he's far from a proven pass rusher, as evidenced by the Dolphins replacing him with Jordan. I just don't see any other monsters on their line apart from Cam Wake. I've certainly not seen any dominance from them in recent years. It's a team strength, but how strong is a whole new question.

    I don't think I've underestimated their receivers, either. If Brandon Gibson is the best they have then it speaks volumes. He's had one good year, two very average years and one solid year. The Rams moved on from him because they felt he wasn't an answer for Sam Bradford. In the 2012 season he was very bland. Two good games but the rest a lot of 2/3 catches for 30/40 yards type deal. It's consistent but it falls well short of a guy being a game changer. He did score 5 touchdowns but 2 of them came from the Jets awful goal line. He only had 4 touchdowns in the previous 3 seasons (Admittedly, he missed time with injury in all those seasons) so it's hard to see him, like Hartline, as a points monster.

    I just don't see either of those grouping being so great.
    First of all, please stop saying "without Wake...blah blah". If any unit loses their best player of course there will be a dropoff. Soliai is a former Pro Bowler (2011) and simply can't be guarded 1 on 1. He demands two blockers almost every time. If anything, Starks is in his prime. He, like Soliai, also demands attention as he can rush the passer. He's healthy and has been for the past two weeks and is is now starting according to the new depth chart. Must not have been paying attention but some sites even list them as a top 5 DT tandem. Olivier Vernon has improved a lot so I wouldn't say "he's far from a proven pass rusher". He was handling Duane Brown, who many tout as the best LT (Thomas is better imo), when we faced the Texans in the preseason. Vernon is actually starting, not Jordan. Dion is actually listed as the 3rd DE behind Vernon and Vaugh Martin. "I've certainly not seen any dominance from them in recent years" Well of course. The Dolphins have been a 6-7 win team for the past four years, they're not going to get a lot of publicity. Just for you: 7th in sacks last season, 12th in 2011, 10th in 2010, and 3rd in 2009. 13th in run defense last year, 3rd in 2011, 7th in 2010, and 18th in 2009. That's without an established DE opposite of Wake and going through 3 defensive coordinators.

    Our receivers are as good as Tannehill makes them. While it isn't the best, the WR corp this year is a huge upgrade from what we had last year. Gibson also led all receivers in 1st down and TD conversion percentage and 43 of his 51 catches were for 1st downs last year. A #3 receiver isn't going to put 800+ yards without Brady, Manning, or Rodgers throwing to him. Sorry.

    The DL whether you like it or not is top 10 which is what I'd call great. WR's are a tossup.

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Enigmatic Evil View Post
    Safety... I call it even as well.
    Woah. Ward is definitely one of the better safeties and I'd probably say him and Jones are about equal but Gipson is no where close to Clemons. Far from even.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    NE Oklahoma
    Posts
    3,390
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 96 Times in 71 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MiamiFAN View Post
    First of all, please stop saying "without Wake...blah blah". If any unit loses their best player of course there will be a dropoff. Soliai is a former Pro Bowler (2011) and simply can't be guarded 1 on 1. He demands two blockers almost every time. If anything, Starks is in his prime. He, like Soliai, also demands attention as he can rush the passer. He's healthy and has been for the past two weeks and is is now starting according to the new depth chart. Must not have been paying attention but some sites even list them as a top 5 DT tandem. Olivier Vernon has improved a lot so I wouldn't say "he's far from a proven pass rusher". He was handling Duane Brown, who many tout as the best LT (Thomas is better imo), when we faced the Texans in the preseason. Vernon is actually starting, not Jordan. Dion is actually listed as the 3rd DE behind Vernon and Vaugh Martin. "I've certainly not seen any dominance from them in recent years" Well of course. The Dolphins have been a 6-7 win team for the past four years, they're not going to get a lot of publicity. Just for you: 7th in sacks last season, 12th in 2011, 10th in 2010, and 3rd in 2009. 13th in run defense last year, 3rd in 2011, 7th in 2010, and 18th in 2009. That's without an established DE opposite of Wake and going through 3 defensive coordinators.

    Our receivers are as good as Tannehill makes them. While it isn't the best, the WR corp this year is a huge upgrade from what we had last year. Gibson also led all receivers in 1st down and TD conversion percentage and 43 of his 51 catches were for 1st downs last year. A #3 receiver isn't going to put 800+ yards without Brady, Manning, or Rodgers throwing to him. Sorry.

    The DL whether you like it or not is top 10 which is what I'd call great. WR's are a tossup.
    Nice post. Glad you dropped by. Forgive me if I tend to disagree with some of the details. For example, I think your QB is shit.

    Just kidding.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Cleveland (Euclid)
    Posts
    5,244
    Thanks
    246
    Thanked 173 Times in 122 Posts
    Blog Entries
    2

    Default

    Maybe Im a homer... but I dont see any strength they have over us...

    WR's? They have a one trick pony and a a top possession guy who is inconsistent..
    We have a 6"3 235 lb Greg Little who can jump through the roof, break tackles, get YAC, and has shown a lot of promise in just 2 seasons after not playing at all his senior year...
    We have their former best WR
    We have Benjamin who can out run mike wallce..

    QB's? Tannehill was worse than Weeden last year stats wise

    Oline? right....

    Dline? No contest..

    Linebackers? Maybe?... no DQJ, Kruger, Sheard... better than what they have..

    Secondary.. Joe Haden... TJ Ward... nuff said... although their #2 and #3 corners may be better

    Runningbacks? Trich is pro bowl bound... they are scavenging

    TE.. Same boat as us, but Cameron at least has upside

    Coaching? We have Norv the burner Turner, and Ray Horton

    I really dont see a contest here

    The time has come! Our Dynasty lies ahead!

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    NE Oklahoma
    Posts
    3,390
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 96 Times in 71 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by PlaygroundLegend View Post
    Maybe Im a homer... but I dont see any strength they have over us...

    WR's? They have a one trick pony and a a top possession guy who is inconsistent..
    We have a 6"3 235 lb Greg Little who can jump through the roof, break tackles, get YAC, and has shown a lot of promise in just 2 seasons after not playing at all his senior year...
    We have their former best WR
    We have Benjamin who can out run mike wallce..

    QB's? Tannehill was worse than Weeden last year stats wise

    Oline? right....

    Dline? No contest..

    Linebackers? Maybe?... no DQJ, Kruger, Sheard... better than what they have..

    Secondary.. Joe Haden... TJ Ward... nuff said... although their #2 and #3 corners may be better

    Runningbacks? Trich is pro bowl bound... they are scavenging

    TE.. Same boat as us, but Cameron at least has upside

    Coaching? We have Norv the burner Turner, and Ray Horton

    I really dont see a contest here
    Maybe. But I would feel a lot better about the game if we had Gordon. If Richardson scores a couple of touchdowns, I think we win.

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by PlaygroundLegend View Post
    Maybe Im a homer... but I dont see any strength they have over us...

    WR's? They have a one trick pony and a a top possession guy who is inconsistent..
    We have a 6"3 235 lb Greg Little who can jump through the roof, break tackles, get YAC, and has shown a lot of promise in just 2 seasons after not playing at all his senior year...
    We have their former best WR
    We have Benjamin who can out run mike wallce..

    QB's? Tannehill was worse than Weeden last year stats wise

    Oline? right....

    Dline? No contest..

    Linebackers? Maybe?... no DQJ, Kruger, Sheard... better than what they have..

    Secondary.. Joe Haden... TJ Ward... nuff said... although their #2 and #3 corners may be better

    Runningbacks? Trich is pro bowl bound... they are scavenging

    TE.. Same boat as us, but Cameron at least has upside

    Coaching? We have Norv the burner Turner, and Ray Horton

    I really dont see a contest here
    Complete homer.

    One trick pony or not, he's better than all of your receivers with the exception of Gordon. Inconsistent or not an average of 8 TD's from a "one trick pony" is what we need considering we don't score enough TD's. Little is indeed good but Hartline excels in route-running and making difficult catches being the less physical receiver. Best receiver? Maybe not. Bess and Hartline were neck and neck; both were reliable and productive with no franchise QB. I love Benjamin, UM fan, but its not a comparison of speed. Its talent. Wallace<>Gordon
    Hartline<>Little
    Gibson<>Bess
    Matthews<>Benjamin

    QB: Tannehill is more elusive and handles the blitz surprisingly well. Stats can go out of the window right now. Who do you think will be better 5 years from now?
    O-Line: .....
    D-Line: You have someone better than Wake? How about Starks? Nope. Could argue that Odrick is better than your DT but he's been playing out of position. Its kind of odd comparing the two as you guys play in a 3-4. Dolphins' 3-4 formation: Starks, Soliai, Odrick as the DE-DT-DE and Vernon/Jordan, Wheeler, Ellerbe, Wake/Misi at LOLB-ILB-ILB-ROLB. Scary.
    LB: The 3-4 again makes it impossible to compare. DQJ is the only true LB there while Kruger is an OLB and Sheard is a 3-4/4-3 DE playing OLB.
    Secondary: Grimes=Haden, Jones=Ward, Clemons>>>Gipson. Your 3rd and 4th CB's must suck because ours do.
    RB: You win.
    TE: About equal. I like our depth a bit more as Clay could breakout like Cameron, Sims providing decent blocking, and Egnew still developing.
    Coaching: Sherman has the better track record for offenses (see Packers from 2000-2005). I'll give you Horton.

  17. #17
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by OldDawgCliff View Post
    Maybe. But I would feel a lot better about the game if we had Gordon. If Richardson scores a couple of touchdowns, I think we win.
    I feel the same way. If you guys had Gordon I would probably mark this down as a L, but you don't. Grimes should be able to handle Little while Patterson....wait a second? Who's playing outside receiver opposite of Little in this game? I hope it isn't Bess. Seeing as though our run D is a strength I'd be surprised if Richardson scores more than 2 TD's.

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by PlaygroundLegend View Post
    Runningbacks? Trich is pro bowl bound... they are scavenging
    Pro Bowl bound? Don't see him beating out Foster, Charles, Spiller, or Rice plus its going to be a draft from now on.

  19. #19
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    NE Oklahoma
    Posts
    3,390
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 96 Times in 71 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MiamiFAN View Post
    I feel the same way. If you guys had Gordon I would probably mark this down as a L, but you don't. Grimes should be able to handle Little while Patterson....wait a second? Who's playing outside receiver opposite of Little in this game? I hope it isn't Bess. Seeing as though our run D is a strength I'd be surprised if Richardson scores more than 2 TD's.
    Actually I haven't a clue. Gordon is really our only true deep threat and he won't be there. Little is actually more a yards after the catch guy. Maybe the deepest threat we will have in the game will be Cameron, the TE. I would suppose that Norv will need to get a little creative. Benjamin may take a few deep strolls. He not big--and I don't know if you knew this or not--but he is rather fast. Seriously, I was hoping they would use Gurley in place of Gordon, but he has been assigned to the practice squad. I guess I will just have to admit that without Gordon, we are severely handicapped. Maybe it is foolhardy to even think we might win. I guess I am mainly counting on Sherman/Tannehill losing it for you.

  20. #20
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Massillon, Ohio
    Posts
    6,142
    Thanks
    96
    Thanked 90 Times in 45 Posts
    Blog Entries
    3

    Default

    Great post BDU, I hope you do this every week! Also some other great posts in this thread ...and I agree with everyone except the guy who's looking through the hideous aqua green lenses.

  21. #21
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    10,235
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 111 Times in 96 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MiamiFAN View Post
    Complete homer.

    One trick pony or not, he's better than all of your receivers with the exception of Gordon. Inconsistent or not an average of 8 TD's from a "one trick pony" is what we need considering we don't score enough TD's. Little is indeed good but Hartline excels in route-running and making difficult catches being the less physical receiver. Best receiver? Maybe not. Bess and Hartline were neck and neck; both were reliable and productive with no franchise QB. I love Benjamin, UM fan, but its not a comparison of speed. Its talent. Wallace<>Gordon
    Hartline<>Little
    Gibson<>Bess
    Matthews<>Benjamin

    QB: Tannehill is more elusive and handles the blitz surprisingly well. Stats can go out of the window right now. Who do you think will be better 5 years from now?
    O-Line: .....
    D-Line: You have someone better than Wake? How about Starks? Nope. Could argue that Odrick is better than your DT but he's been playing out of position. Its kind of odd comparing the two as you guys play in a 3-4. Dolphins' 3-4 formation: Starks, Soliai, Odrick as the DE-DT-DE and Vernon/Jordan, Wheeler, Ellerbe, Wake/Misi at LOLB-ILB-ILB-ROLB. Scary.
    LB: The 3-4 again makes it impossible to compare. DQJ is the only true LB there while Kruger is an OLB and Sheard is a 3-4/4-3 DE playing OLB.
    Secondary: Grimes=Haden, Jones=Ward, Clemons>>>Gipson. Your 3rd and 4th CB's must suck because ours do.
    RB: You win.
    TE: About equal. I like our depth a bit more as Clay could breakout like Cameron, Sims providing decent blocking, and Egnew still developing.
    Coaching: Sherman has the better track record for offenses (see Packers from 2000-2005). I'll give you Horton.
    Because I live in FL, I watch the Dolphins in addition to being a Browns fan. The Dolphins do have better receivers than the Browns, although Bess-Gibson are pretty even. As I noted the other day, Gibson is going to give the Browns secondary fits.

    I think the Browns front 7 is a little better, but a lot of Browns fans here badly undereestimate the Dolphins front 7 defense. Browns have a fine OL but the Dolphins are going to get a fair amount of pressure on Weeden.

    The oddsmakers have this is a pick 'em game and I agree.

  22. #22
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    15
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by TheBestPlayersPlay View Post
    Great post BDU, I hope you do this every week! Also some other great posts in this thread ...and I agree with everyone except the guy who's looking through the hideous aqua green lenses.


    Don't hate!

  23. #23
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Kiirtland Snow Hell
    Posts
    3,395
    Thanks
    14
    Thanked 14 Times in 10 Posts

    Default

    the only strength that will matter is the W Miami will have at games end...
    Its Offense baby!!!!!" "ITS
    OFFENSE!!!!!

  24. #24
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    1,452
    Thanks
    15
    Thanked 49 Times in 35 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nickers View Post
    the only strength that will matter is the W Miami will have at games end...
    If your anything your consistent.

    I think this game will be decided by Weeden/Tannehill and turnovers as Lamar Miller has a tendency to fumble.

    Our D-line is still better as we have quality young depth from Taylor to Kitchen to Hughes and they ain't taking no break.

    Mike Pettine - 8-20-14 - "It's easy to look at the numbers, but when you look at the tape it tells a very different story." 12-3-14 - "His(Hoyer) preparation is better."

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •