Browns - The Watson Contract: Poison Pill Edition |

Browns The Watson Contract: Poison Pill Edition

DawgFan

In NFL HELL since 1964
We as Browns fans have long lamented the 5yr/$230M dollar contract given to DW, along with the 3-1st round picks (plus) given for the right to make that contract. But wait...there is sooooo much more.

The Browns have restructured this contract FIVE (5) times:
March, 2023 they added insurance
August 29, 2024 they converted $44.79M to signing bonus to create cap space
December 27, 2024 another rework due to season ending injury
March 6, 2025 they converted another $36M to signing bonus to create cap space
March 6, 2026 they again converted $44.7M to signing bonus
(they also created 2 dummy/voidable years in 2027 and 2028 to carry the bonus's until later)

But wait, there is more...
During the December 2024 restructuring the Browns added a POISON PILL of a $200M base salary for 2029. This is totally non-guaranteed but will become FULLY GUARANTEED if DW is on the roster by March 13, 2027.

All of the contract manipulations in the first 5 lines are understandable. Push the cap hit down the road in an effort to field a good team (hahaha, swing and a miss).

However, creating a $200M base salary for 2029 that becomes fully guaranteed if the is on the roster by March 13, 2027? Why? What is the purpose?

And just as important, WHY ANNOUNCE IT THE SAME DAY YOU ANNOUNCE HIM AS STARTER FOR 2026?!?!

I have seen some explanations and none of them make sense. Some imply it was to create a 'structure' of the end of the contract to ensure the Browns release him by then. Some say it has something to do with the post-June 1 cut...that it somehow enables that. Some just are too crazy to reiterate here.

The fact is, all this 'poison pill' does is to force the Browns to release him by March 13, 2027. If he sucks, release him. If he does well, release him. The only other option is to renegotiate a MINIMUM of a 3yr/$280M contract to encompass the remaining bonus's due and the $200M 2029 contract...and have that in BEFORE March 13, 2027.

So again, I ask why?

Obviously Monken had nothing to do with it, he wasn't here in 2024.
Just as obviously, Andrew Berry was in charge of writing it.
Very likely from the stat DW was a Jimmy Haslam interference case where he mandated we trade for him at any cost.
The trade cost (3 1sts plus plus plus) and the contract (unprecedented) made Berry look weak in NFL circles.

The only logical conclusion I can draw is that Andrew Berry put in the 'poison pill' to end the farce. To end the pain. To provide an almost sure-fire way to force DW out of Cleveland regardless of JH's interference. (Keep in mind, JH attended DW's wedding earlier this year). As for why announce the existence of the 'poison pill' the day DW is named starter? Pretty obvious it was an attempt to appease the Browns fanbase by telling them it's only this year. The mistake will be removed no later than March 13, 2027.

To God's Ears!!!
 
hmm, so Its not a cult for #2.he just looks like an NFL starting QB to all.

dance charles GIF
 
MSN (Link) basically it's saying they are starting Watson so he can play himself out of Cleveland (He's gonna suck) so they can avoid the poison pill 200k payout by releasing him before March 13th near.. tick tick tick... is is March yet?
 
It looks like their plan for a clean break from that Watson contract. Not a problem until it is.

What if he plays well enough to not allow Sanders to start? What if Sanders starts a couple games and gets hurt?
It can get complicated down the road but most all of it is PR control until they cut him.
 
It looks like their plan for a clean break from that Watson contract. Not a problem until it is.

What if he plays well enough to not allow Sanders to start? What if Sanders starts a couple games and gets hurt?
It can get complicated down the road but most all of it is PR control until they cut him.
This isn't hard. If Sanders played well enough, he would be starting. He didn't. He's not. Monken started a walk-on over 2 very highly rated players because he was the better QB... and he won two national championships with him. He plays the guy he thinks gives the team the best chance to win.

Sanders will play at some point this season (either b/c of injury or Watson failing) and we will see what he has. Chances are, he isn't the answer either.

2027 we get to break free of Watson and bring in our QBOTF. Unfortunately, we have to get through this season to get there.
 
"I don't Sanders is ready."
should not be the reason to start Watson.
"Watson is a deplorable human and sucks as a football player" should be the reason to play Sanders. Or Guy from Section 5, row 11, seat 3.

It's the same failed logic why they got Watson in the first place.
"Because Baker Mayfield isn't perfect".
That doesn't mean the alternative (250M, all draft picks, to a guy who is getting sued by half the town he lives in) is better.

It's all just so dumb.

They should've cut him last year, eat the crap this year, and continue next year.
Or, never have made the trade in the first place, but Jimmy Haslam is Jimmy Haslam.
 
Back
Top Bottom